- Bright Family Papers, 1876/19331
- Charles Edward Gary, Jr. Papers, 1870/2000, bulk 1940/19801
- Cole-Lane Collection, 1794/19341
- Eastern Lunatic Asylum Ledgers, 1876/1916, bulk 1876/19031
- First Baptist Church collection, 1866/20171
- Galt Papers (III), 1750/19911
- Geddy-Harris Archive Records, 1773/1959, bulk 1890/19401
- Hall Family Papers, 1810/20071
- Henry Denison Cole Papers, 1786/19391
- James City County and City of Williamsburg Personal Property Tax Books, 1865/19491
- Janet C. Kimbrough Williamsburg Area History Collection, 1873/19941
- John Garland Pollard Papers, 1683/1968, bulk 1856/19371
- John Turner Henley Papers, 1857/1921, bulk 1918/19211
- Julia W. Oxrieder Papers, 1877/19981
- Lee Family Papers, 1858/1976, bulk 1900/19501