- Mary Eleanor Davis Ries Papers, 1870-1967, 1870/19671
- Myers-Burrage-Graham papers (I), Group A, 1776/19251
- Office of Admission records, 1861/20211
- Office of the President: Board of Visitors Records, 1908/20251
- Phi Beta Kappa, Alpha Chapter Records, 1776/2013, bulk 1888/19551
- Philomathean Literary Society Records, 1874/19381
- Phoenix Literary Society Records, 1873/19411
- Pulaski Club Records, 1877/20141
- Richard Lee Morton papers, 1756/2006, bulk 1930/19691
- Samuel D. Rockenbach papers, 1889/19451
- Spew Marrow Agricultural Club Papers, 1876/19341
- Stonewall Jackson papers, 1844/19151
- Summer Session Records, 1912-2000, 1912/20001
- The Pauline Home for the Aged (Columbus, Ohio) Records, 1905/1944, bulk 1915/19351
- Violet McDougall Pollard papers, 1907/1976, bulk 1933/19681