- Jack and Jill Nursery and Kindergarten Records, 1949/1975, bulk 19501
- Jamestown 400th Anniversary Collection, 2007, bulk 20071
- Jamestown Corporation Records, 1946/19791
- Janet C. Kimbrough Williamsburg Area History Collection, 1873/19941
- Jean Harrup Cogle Papers, 1949/2008, bulk 1970/19901
- Jefferson Davis Papers, 1858/19041
- John Alexander Graham Papers, 1910/1947, bulk 1915/19473
- John Branch Green Papers, 1924/19291
- John Marshall Pageant Records, 1922, bulk 19221
- John Tyler Papers, 1840/19311
- Joseph Bryan Memorial Service and Window Dedication Program, 19091
- Joseph Daragan Papers, 1967/19711
- Julia W. Oxrieder Papers, 1877/19981
- Lexington Presbyterian Church collection, 1824/1927, bulk 1877/19272
- Lloyd H. and Ruth Elizabeth Williams Papers, 1917/2008, bulk 1947/19591