- Alpha Delta Gamma Records, 1993/20121
- Alumni Band Organization Records, 1986/2012, bulk 1986/20001
- Carl A. "Pappy" Fehr papers, 1907/2012, bulk 1945/19741
- Carlton Casey Papers, 1894/19991
- Charter Day collection, 1859/20221
- Christmas Activities Collection, 1942/20021
- Claudia Stevens papers, 1967/20231
- College of William & Mary. Lesbian and Gay Union Records, 1980/1997, bulk 1984/19871
- Commencement Exercises collection, 1831/20241
- Covenant Players Records, 1979/19981
- Department of History records, 1959/20231
- Department of Kinesiology Records, 1954/20051
- Department of Music records, 1920/20191
- Department of Physics Records, 1960/20051
- Elizabeth White Willard Papers, 1951/20081