- Alumni Association Records, 1833/2014, bulk 1950/20051
- Augusta and Rockingham County, Va. Methodist Episcopal Conference Minute Book (Mount Solon), 1875/19031
- Board of Visitors records, 1757/20231
- College Papers Collection, 1880/19991
- Faculty Assembly Records, 1729/20081
- Fairfax Harrison Papers, 1736/19451
- Galt Papers (I), 1745/18921
- Gloucester Circuit of the Methodist Church Records, 1825/19101
- Henry Denison Cole Papers, 1786/19391
- John Garland Pollard Papers, 1683/1968, bulk 1856/19371
- Julia W. Oxrieder Papers, 1877/19981
- Monroe County (W. Va.) Court Records and Miscellaneous Papers, 1751/19271
- Office of Admission records, 1861/20211
- Pulaski Club Records, 1877/20141
- Richard Lee Morton papers, 1756/2006, bulk 1930/19691