- Abbot E. Smith Papers, 1930/19391
- Alexander Brown Papers (II), 1748/19001
- Anthony Reiff Papers, 18561
- Art Song of Williamsburg Records, 2000/20071
- Austin-Twyman Papers, 1765/19391
- Betty Washington Lewis family papers, 1783/18441
- Book Dedication by Thomas Jefferson to the Library of the College of William and Mary1
- Burwell-Catlett Papers, 1794/18871
- Carl R. Dolmetsch Papers, 1751/19901
- Caskie Stinnett Papers, 1919/1998, bulk 1950/19931
- Cecil McCulley Papers, 1945/2005, bulk 1945/19771
- Chappelear Collection, 1788/19591
- Charles Campbell Papers, 1743/18961
- Charles L. Quittmeyer Papers, 1983/19851
- Christopher Bram Papers, 1968/2014, bulk 1975/20001