- Booton-Modesitt Family Papers, 1809/1880, bulk 1820/18501
- Charter Day collection, 1859/20221
- Commencement Exercises collection, 1831/20241
- Ephemera Collection, 1800/20141
- James Madison, Sr. Papers, 1792/19311
- John Tyler, Jr. Papers, 1800/19281
- Mary and Hannah Gibbons Papers, 1743/18901
- Matthew Whaley School Collection, 1850/2012, bulk 1880/19601
- Myers-Burrage-Graham papers (I), Group A, 1776/19251
- Schuyler Otis Bland Papers, 1862/19501
- Williamsburg (Va.) Area Ephemera Collection, 1858/20151