- Amos Koontz Papers I, 1809/1965, bulk 1936/19651
- Anatole and Vladimir Kalichevsky Papers, 1871/19551
- Carter Lowance Papers, 1860/1993, bulk 1942/19881
- Charles Edward Gary, Jr. Papers, 1870/2000, bulk 1940/19801
- Dora and Cara Armistead Papers, 1880/19501
- Edward Belvin Collection of Williamsburg and James City County materials, 1874/19871
- Grigsby-Galt Papers, 1736/1982, bulk 1840/19301
- Hall Family Papers, 1810/20071
- Hart Papers I and II, 1847/19341
- John Garland Pollard Papers, 1683/1968, bulk 1856/19371
- Lee Family Papers, 1858/1976, bulk 1900/19501
- Office of Admission records, 1861/20211
- Rembert Family Papers, 1885/1965, bulk 1910/19551
- Royal Arch Masons. New Jerusalem Chapter No. 3 (Wiscasset, Me.) Minute Books and Certificates, 1877/1978, bulk 1877/19541