- Department of English records, 1922/20131
- Faculty Senate Minutes, 1969/20071
- Frank Shatz Papers, 1965/20221
- Fred Frechette Papers, 1930/2000, bulk 1950/20001
- James City County Oral History Collection, 1983/1986, bulk 19841
- Lewis B. Puller, Jr. papers, 1984/19921
- Manuscripts Audiovisual Collection, 1920/20131
- Michael Fox Collection of Herbert H. Bateman Campaign Material, 1982/19991
- Theodore C. (Ted) DeLaney, Jr. Collection, 1940/20201
- William & Mary Hip Hop collection, 1985/2019, bulk 2012/20141
- William Ingham Papers, 1945/20131